Your #1 Nissan Skyline & Infiniti G35 Resource

Home - Press Reports - R34 Nissan Skyline GT-R
 
Advertisement  
 
site nav:
  sponsored links:
 
bbc top gear magazine
Page 1 | 2 | 3

We appreciate the support of BBC Top Gear in presenting you the following comparison test of the R34 Nissan Skyline GT-R, Porsche 911 GT3, Mitsubishi Lancer Evo VI, and BMW M5.

BBC Top Gear is Britain's most comprehensive and authoritative car magazine, offering an independent and unique perspective like no other motoring mag. Every month you'll find informative and original features on every aspect of motoring and car buying, plus road tests and reviews of all the latest models. Top Gear's innovative way of looking at and writing about vehicles ensures that you'll never be bored, and with customer satisfaction the main concern, it's an editorial voice you can trust. Please read the article below and form your own picture...

Subscribe

comparison test

Imagine the scene. It's a nightmare scenario, but try all the same. The powers that be have decided to ban all private cars from the public road. You have only one night of personal petrol-powered excitement left before the dreaded rule is enforced. Which car would you choose to spend those last dark hours with - to drive to its limits until the dawn comes up? We had sleepless nights trying to dream up our wish-list and then spent one on these:

The Nissan Skyline R34 GT-R, Porsche 911 GT3, Mitsubishi Lancer Evo VI GSR and BMW M5.
Now we know which one to grab for a one-night stand if it ever comes true...

 

In the fading light the Porsche seems to hover a few inches above the ground, like some silver ghost racer. The darkness has merged with the low-profile tyresPorsche 911 GT3 and filled in the spaces between wheelarch and wheel, doorsill and tarmac. But then there's not much to fill. Only a few millimetres separate the top of the tyre from the bottom of the wheelarch and mere centimetres prevent the bodywork from scraping the ground. Only a lack of competition numbers distinguishes this GT3, the latest 911, from a racing car. Those front headlamps may still take a little getting used to, but from the side there's no denying the beauty and history in that 911 shape. It's changed, of course, over the years. But the alternations have been soft and gentle. Like a pebble that's lain at the bottom of a riverbed, the 911 has been smoothed and polished ever-closer to perfection. Apart from the red brake callipers and the gold and red coat of arms on the nose, there's hardly any real colour to this 911. So in the darkness it floats, somehow not quite of this world.

R34 Nissan Skyline GT-RThe machine next to the 911 is most definitely of this world; right here and right now. Cars do not leave the factory with a higher 'in-your-face' quota than the Nissan Skyline R34 GT-R. Even in day-light it looks evil. It's a big, solid lump of thing, the Skyline - longer and wider than the 911 and 50 times uglier. But it's the right sort of ugliness. The Skyline is ugly in the same way as a mid- '80s Group B rally MG Metro 6R4 was ugly. It's the same sort of 'I don't care what I look like; I'll get the job done, you'll see' school of styling.

Mitsubishi Lancer Evo VI GSRMitsubishi's Lancer Evo 6 GSR looks like it was designed by someone who never went to school, never mind design college. It doesn't look like he's quite finished yet, either. At any moment he might come wandering out of the darkness with a chainsaw to hack out a bit more cooling space around the front, or a hammer and some nails to add a third tier to the rear spoiler. The Evo's looks are unreformed and unreachable borstal boy. Ram-raiding? Drive-bys? Bank-jobs? Been there, done that. And won the World Rally Driver's Championship for the last three years.

Forest night stages, gravel and oily-fingernailed mechanics waiting in arclitBMW M5 service areas are light years away from blue-chip world of the blue-propelled BMW M5. The sophisticated styling of the normal 5-Series has been altered only slightly to accommodate the needs of this, the high-performance version. The changes include bigger wheels and tyres, a deeper front spoiler, lower body stance and the merest hint of a bootlid spoiler. It bares no resemblance at all to the smash-and-grab looks of the Japanese machines. This BMW could never be caught at the scene of the crime. At best, there might be some grainy black and white security video footage of it leaving the car park of a multi-national, three days before the share price collapsed.

BMW M5 Engine
Porsche 911 GT3 Engine
Mitsubishi Lancer Evo VI GSR Engine
RB26DETT

But what's it doing here? After all the other three: Porsche 911 GT3, Nissan Skyline R34 GT-R and Mitsubishi Lancer Evo VI GSR all have, as Ann Widdicombe might put it, 'something of the night' about them. Surely the BMW is too civilised to keep such dark company?

Think again. For a start, the rear-wheel-drive £59,995 M5 has the biggest, most powerful and torquiest engine of all. The five-litre V8 produces 400bhp and lb-ft of torque, making it the most powerful engine ever to leave a BMW factory.

Porsche's 3.6-litre GT3 engine was developed from the flat- six used in the racing 911 GT1. Rear-mounted, it delivers 360bhp and 273lb-ft of torque to the rear-wheels of the £76,500 GT3.

Both the Japanese cars are front-engined and four-wheel drive and both turn out 276bhp. The Mitsubishi's single-turbo, four-cylinder two-litre produces 275lb-ft; it's the performance bargain of the decade at £30,995.

There's no confirmed price for the Skyline yet, but it's going to be around £54,000, which gets you twin-turbos, a 2.6 litre straight-six and 14lb-ft of torque more than the Mitsubishi.

That's how they stand on paper, anyway - four potentially brilliant driver's cars. We've spent all day at Bruntingthorpe Proving Ground, but now the night has come and if ever there were cars suited to travel in the hours of darkness, it is these.

Page 1 of 3

1 | 2 | 3

 

Continue reading

R34 GT-R related: History | Facts & Figures | Road Test | Showroom | Wallpapers

 
 

Copyright © 2000 - 2002 JB car pages. All rights reserved. Download Flash-Player here.

Site Map
Site Map
Go to Top
Go to Top