Your #1 Nissan Skyline & Infiniti G35 Resource

Home - Press Reports - R34 Nissan Skyline GT-R
 
Advertisement  
 
site nav:
  sponsored links:
 
bbc top gear magazine
Page 1 | 2 | 3

We appreciate the support of BBC Top Gear in presenting you this comparison test of the R34 Nissan Skyline GT-R, Porsche 911 GT3, Mitsubishi Lancer Evo VI, and BMW M5.

BBC Top Gear is Britain's most comprehensive and authoritative car magazine, offering an independent and unique perspective like no other motoring mag. Every month you'll find informative and original features on every aspect of motoring and car buying, plus road tests and reviews of all the latest models. Top Gear's innovative way of looking at and writing about vehicles ensures that you'll never be bored, and with customer satisfaction the main concern, it's an editorial voice you can trust. Please read the article below and form your own picture...

Subscribe

comparison test

The security guard steps into the pool of light outside his cabin. He raises the barrier and waves the cars to follow him as he walks forward to open the perimeter steel gates. Behind him, the 911 trundles slowly along. It feels like driving a racing car into a holding area. The clutch is sharp and the engine rattles at idle like a broken toy. Even at crawling speeds you're jiggled and bounced around inside the cabin.

Porsche has a theory that no matter how bad things get, it's the specialist sports car car makers who will survive, not the manufacturers who turn out drab little boxes for something as mundane as personal transport. The German companyPorsche 911 GT3 believes that even if one day all cars are banned from the road, people will buy sports cars and drive them simply for pure pleasure.

And the GT3 is halfway down that road already, even more so with the Club Sport package that comes with Recaro racing seats, a roll-cage and an interior battery cut-off switch. But despite its racetrack set-up, this 911 is still free to travel the Queen's Highway. And we know where there are some cracking bits of it that have yet to fall under the Gatso's shadow.

As the last car rolls out, the security guard shuts the gates and leaves us outside in the dark, with four cars quick enough to outrun the devil himself. The Porsche feels keen to be off, to the point of nervous agitation, its rattly idling engine making the seats and steering wheel vibrate. Inside the BMW business-class cabin, all feels calm until you squeeze the accelerator pedal and flick the rev-counter up to 3,000rpm - it's then the V8 signals its intention with a great growl of power, strong enough to shake the left-hand side of the bonnet. The Skyline feels alive inside too, but not in a raw animal way. It idles quietly, but all the time its multi-mode dash-top computer flickers away, showing seven different readingsR34 Nissan Skyline GT-R simultaneously, from boost pressure to exhaust temperature. As it checks and rechecks ist data in preparation for the charge to come, you get the unsettling feeling that it has almost enough technology to run itself and dis-pense with the driver completely.

Little happens inside the Evo's cabin to hint at the immense performance about to be unleashed. But give it the full rally start - it'll take 6,000rpm before the clutch is dropped - and it launches itself through the air with a viciousness of an assassin's switchblade. Through first, second and third gears, which come up so quickly in the close-ratio gearbox, the acceleration is lethal. It's almost Porsche-shaming and with a few spits of rain on the ground there would be no question - the Evo's four-wheel-drive system would see to that.

But the night is dry and the Porsche has power and, weighing just 1,350kg, lightness is on its side. There is no traction control, though, so it can't be lobbed off the line like the Evo. Steady the revs out just above 2,000rpm, drop the clutchMitsubishi Lancer Evo VI GSR and - if you use the throttle just right to balance the engine's power against the tyre's traction - the 911 will rocket forward into the darkness and nothing else will live with it.

The Evo runs it close, and up to 60mph it's just one tenth of a second behind the GT3. Most of the time the Mitsubishi's hard-stressed engine is surprisingly quiet inside the cabin, and it certainly can't compete with 911's guttural wail. By the time 120mph comes up on the speedo, though, the Evo is starting to feel like a spent force, while the GT3 is still a howling, screaming streak of acceleration.

Compared with the manic approach of Porsche's straight-six, the BMW's V8 is a deep well of tranquility. Unlike the 911, it comes with traction control, but when it's switched off the M5 requires the same delicate throttle balance for quick getaways. Up to 4,000rpm it's very refined, but above that the thunder starts with a deep-throated growl. The M5's V8 serves up a never-ending supply of torque. It's not the quickest-revving engine, but while the rev-counter needle may not slice rapidly round, the speedometer needle does, sweeping into treble figures with effortless ease.

BMW M5This 1,795kg saloon may post the slowest 0-60 time, but do not mistake it for a slow car. Study the spec table for a while and you'll see it matches the Evo from 30-70mph through the gears, gives the best in-gear acceleration and is second fastest to 140mph.

The M5 is not just phenomenally quick for a big four-door saloon, it's simply phenomenally quick - full stop.

So too, of course, is the beast from Nissan which, keen students of the apocalypse may wish to note, weighs in at 1,666kg. As with the Evo, the best technique is tons of revs and off the clutch as quickly as possible. The Skyline's continuously variable four-wheel-drive system ensures that all the power is normally delivered to the rear wheels and only transferred forwards when needed, so it takes off from the line feeling more like a rear-wheel-drive car. Up to 4,000rpm the engine feels disappointingly flat and lifeless, but above that, when both turbos cut in, it truly comes alive. It sounds good too - not as snarly as the Porsche, but equally addictive in its own way.

The performance of all four is little short of electrifying. Sure, if we were driving on German autobahns the 911 would simply run away with it, but on British roads these cars are all staggeringly good - all wheat and no chaff. And how fast they feel. It really seems that since we left the proving ground they have all doubled their horsepower. A sharp burst of the throttle in any of them sets the black hedgerows rushing by, and it feels so much more invigorating than running thePorsche 911 GT3 near-flat-out on the two-mile-long Bruntingthorpe straight. It's the narrow-ness of the roads, the corners and the trees that give the reference points and make the performance such a buzz.

We're not talking about going mental here, just cracking along at a crisp pace on uncluttered roads. The commuters have long since gone to bed, the tractors are tucked away and won't be doing any more work until tomorrow morning's sun has burned the dew off. But the going is just fine for us.

Page 2 of 3

1 | 2 | 3

Previous page

Continue reading

R34 GT-R related: History | Facts & Figures | Road Test | Showroom | Wallpapers

 
 

Copyright © 2000 - 2002 JB car pages. All rights reserved. Download Flash-Player here.

Site Map
Site Map
Go to Top
Go to Top